Scott Kinne First Heritage Mortgage

Scott Kinne's Mortgage information Blog

  • About Scott
  • Testimonials
  • Resources
    • First Time Home Buyer Tips
    • First Time Home Seller Tips
    • Closing Costs
    • Home Appraisal
    • Home Inspection
    • Affordable Credit Repair
    • Interest Rates
    • Loan Programs
    • Loan Process
    • Loan Checklist
    • Mortgage Glossary
    • Mortgage FAQ
  • Main Website
  • Contact
  • Apply

Which Model Is More Accurate : The Case-Shiller Index Or The Home Price Index?

September 9, 2010 by Scott Kinne Leave a Comment

Home Price Index from April 2007 peak

The private-sector Case-Shiller Index reported home values up 5 percent nationwide in June. The government’s own Home Price Index, however, reached a different conclusion.

According to the Federal Home Finance Agency, month-to-month home values fell 0.3 percent in June, and values are down by 1.7 percent from June 2009.

So, as a home buyer and/or homeowner , by which valuation model should you make your bets?  Perhaps neither. 

This is because both the Case-Shiller Index and the Home Price have inherent methodology flaws, the most glaring of which is their respective sample sets. 

The Case-Shiller sample set, for example, comes from just 20 cities across the country — and they’re not even the 20 most populated cities. Together, the Case-Shiller cities represent just 9 percent of the overall U.S. population. 

That’s hardly representative of the housing stock overall.

By comparison, the Home Price Index tracks home sales everywhere — every city in every state — but it specifically excludes certain properties.  The Home Price Index does not track sales of homes for which the financing comes from agencies other than Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. This means that as FHA loans grow in popularity, the pool of Home Price Index-eligible homes is reducing. 

The HPI ignores homes backed by “jumbo” loans, too.

Therefore, the “right” model for home values cannot come from national data at all — it can only come locally. Neither Case-Shiller nor the government has the tools to get as granular as a neighborhood. A real estate agent in the area does, however.

The best way to get a pulse for what’s happening in markets right now is to talk to somebody with good data.

Filed Under: Home Values Tagged With: Home Price Index,HPI,Case Shiller Index

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scott Kinne

Contact Scott

Vice President, Senior Loan Officer
NMLS ID #182351
Office: 703.293.6146
Mobile: 571.237.6241
Fax: 571.317.2478
skinne@fhmtg.com

Licensed In Maryland, Virginia, Washington D.C., West Virginia
  LOAN APPLICATION
  FREE RATE QUOTE

Connect with Me!

Sign Up For My Free Newsletter

Categories

Recent Posts

  • S&P Case-Shiller Home Price Indices: Home Prices Fall In November
  • Is It Worth It to Put More Than 20 Percent Down?
  • What You Need To Know About A Closed-End Second Mortgage
  • What’s Ahead For Mortgage Rates This Week – January 30, 2023
Equal Housing Lender
nmlsconsumeraccess.org
First Heritage Mortgage, LLC, Company NMLS ID #86548

Our Location

3201 Jermantown Road
Suite 800
Fairfax, VA 22030
Business: 703-293-6146
Cellphone: 571-237-6241

Copyright © 2023 · Powered by MySMARTblog